Cutler Cay photo 1

Cutler Cay

Cutler Bay

For Sale

For Rent

List Price

$769K - $2.2M

Year Built

2006

About Cutler Cay

Cutler Cay in Cutler Bay offers an exclusive waterfront lifestyle with its elegant single-family residences ranging from 2,496 to 5,090 square feet. This gated community boasts stunning lake and canal views, complemented by luxurious amenities such as a clubhouse, gym, and tennis courts. Residents enjoy the added convenience of HOA services including internet and TV, while the community's prime location provides quick access to Old Cutler Road. With its impressive security features and potential for rental income, Cutler Cay is an attractive investment for those seeking both comfort and prestige in South Florida living.

Hala Huneidi

halahuneidiproperties@gmail.com

Exclusive availability at Cutler Cay

Key Building Details

Neighborhood
Cutler Bay
Avg Price / Sq Ft

$289

Avg Assoc. Fee

$499 – $524 / mo

Sq Ft

2,496–5,333

Sales Stats

Key averages for this building

Avg List Price

$1,165,316

Avg List Price / Sq Ft

$289

Avg Sale Price

$1,106,091*

*Past 6 months

Avg Sale Price / Sq Ft

$253*

*Past 6 months

152*

Avg Days on Market

*Past 6 months

Sales History

Sold by month

October 20263
September 20262
August 20260
July 20262
June 20261
May 20263

Listings at Cutler Cay

Unit
$1,300,0004 days on Market
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

Genstone Realty

Unit
$1,155,000
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

Compass Florida, LLC

Unit
$1,289,000
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

Coldwell Banker Realty

Unit
$1,250,000
5 bd5 ba
For Sale

Charles Rutenberg Realty FTL

Unit
$1,199,999
5 bd5 ba
For Sale

Skylight Realty International

Unit
$779,000
4 bd3 ba
For Sale

Coldwell Banker Realty

Unit
$910,000
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

Florida Select Realty

Unit
$1,100,000
5 bd5 ba
For Sale

Coldwell Banker Realty

Unit
$999,999
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

BHHS EWM Realty

Unit
$1,125,000
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

Compass Florida, LLC

Unit
$769,000
4 bd4 ba
For Sale

The Kellado Group LLC

Unit
$1,225,000
5 bd4 ba
For Sale

Elite Sales Group

Building Amenities

Pool & Spa

Above Ground, Association, Auto Pool Clean, Community, Concrete, Equipment Stays, Fenced, Free Form, Heated, Hot Tub, In Ground, Pool Bath, Pool Equipment, Pool/Spa Combo, Private, Screen Enclosure, Solar Heat

Sport & Fitness

Gym, Lawn/Pool Maintenance, Pool, Tennis, Tennis Court(s), Whirlpool

Parking

2 Spaces, Additional Spaces Available, Attached, Attached Carport, Carport, Circular Driveway, Covered, Detached Carport, Driveway, Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s), Garage, Garage Door Opener, Golf Cart Parking, Guest, On Street, Parking Garage, Paver Block, Slab/Strip

General Amenities

Bar, Clubhouse, Game Room, Gated Community, Home Owners Association, Mandatory Hoa, On-Site Management, Other Subdivision - See Remarks, Paved Road, Pickleball, Picnic Area, Private Roads, Public Road, Recreation Facilities, Sauna, Security Patrol, Sidewalks, Spa, Street Lights, Subdivision Restrictions, Underground Utilities

Gated Community

Yes

Pet Policy

Pet Friendly

Additional Details

Waterfront

Waterfront Access, Canal Front, Lagoon, Lake, Lake Access, Lake Front, Lake Privileges, Mangrove Front, WF/No Ocean Access, WF/Ocean Access, WF/Pool/No Ocean Access, Canal, City Lights, Clubhouse, Garden, Lake, Pool View, Water View

Exterior Features

Awning(s), Balcony, Barbecue, Barbeque, Built-In Grill, Built-in Barbecue, Fruit Trees, Lighting, Open Balcony, Outdoor Living Area, Outdoor Shower, Room For Pool, Screened Balcony, Tennis Court(s)

Security Features

Building Security, Burglar Alarm, Complex Fenced, Curr Owner Wind Mit, Curr Owner Wind Mitig Cert Avail, Fire Alarm, Fire Sprinklers, Gated Community, Gated with Guard, Key Card Entry, Key Card Entry Parking, Lobby Attended, Owned Burglar Alarm, Security Fence, Security Guard, Security Patrol, Security System, Security System Leased, Smoke Detector, TV Monitor, Walled

Construction

Brick, Concrete Block (CBS), Concrete Block with Brick, Frame, Slab Construction, Stucco

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly mortgage payment

Estimated Monthly Payment: $5,377/mo

Home Price
USD
Down Payment
USD
%
Interest Rate
%
Property Tax Rate
%
HOA / mo
USD
Insurance / mo
USD
Loan Type
Principal & Interest
$3,949
Property Taxes
$705
Home Insurance
$224
HOA
$499

This calculator provides estimates for informational purposes only and does not constitute a loan offer or financial advice. Actual rates, terms, and payments may vary.

Location in Cutler Bay

Nearby Schools